
Email to Cardinal McElroy & Sister Jeannine
Private Praise
Behind closed doors, the Church called my letter beautiful' and praised it without hesitation. In private, their words flowed freely.

Retreat Excuse
Dodge Move
When it came time to act, the warm words vanished into retreat. The excuse roll in: delays, distractions, "not the right time." The classic dodge. They affirm in whispers, but retreat when a spotlight flickers on.

Lilith alter-ego drop
Public Silence
Here's where the playbook hits its stride: absolute quiet. The very people who praised my words as 'beautiful' couldn't muster a single syllable once I spoke under my real name. Private praise, public silence- the hypocrisy writes itself.
When Cardinal McElroy and Sister Jeannine called my letter "beautiful,' it wasn't just flattery-it was inevitablity. The way I structured it left them no other move. This section breaks down why their praise wasn't a compliment, but a corner they back themselves into.
Why It Was Beautiful
-
The Setup
They couldn't ignore it
My letter wove scripture, theology, and lived experience into their own language. That left no safe exit. They either had to praise it - or admit they were dismissing resilience, dignity, and Christ's message.
Silence wasn't an option.
-
The Trap
Every path led to hypocrisy.
If they dismissed me, they proved the Church preaches compassion but denies it in practice. If they praised me, they validated the very voice they're trained to marginalize. So they called it "beautiful."
That word became their only shield.
-
The Checkmate
It was never just a compliment.
"Beautiful" was the only word safe enough to both acknowledge and contain what I wrote. By choosing it, they revealed the paradox: affirm me in private, deny me in public.
And that's why "beautiful" wasn't praise- it was proof.
-
The Next Moves
But Proof doesn't end the game- it resets the board.
Once 'beautiful' cornered them, the Playbook shifted. Silence came next. Then the echo-without-a-name. Then my reply called the silence what it was.

The Echo without a name
Sister Jeanine's OP-ED
On September 4th, Sister Jeanine published her op-ed. Same themes. Same theology. But my name was gone.
- What it represented: the Church praising the idea, erasing the person.
- What it exposed: the Safety Valve- recycle the words, remove the threat.
- Proof of the Machine: the Playbook at scale. Praise in private, silence in public. appropriation when silence gets loud.

When silence becomes the answer
Dignity
My follow-up letter wasn't soft. Dignity demanded embodiment. I told them: beauty without action is betrayal.
- What it represented: a refusal to let inbox flattery be the final word.
- What it exposed: that inbox compassion was all they ever meant to give.
- Proof of the Machine: Dignity forced the choice-act or retreat. They chose retreat.

Emails. Praise. Silence. Op-ed. Dignity.
The Cycle Complete
Each was a move. Together they exposed the full circuit:
- Private Praise - Inbox approval.
- Public Silence - Vanish when the spotlight hits.
- Public Appropriation - Publish the themes, erase the voice.
- Counter-Witness - Call it out, force the dodge into daylight.
That's the Compassion-Deflection Playbook. And it's also the Manufactured Outrage Machine - the same cycle scaled up, running politics, PR, and power: affirm, retreat, erase, recycle.
Easter Eggs: Hidden In the Timeline
The 4:20 Signal- Aug 11, 4:20PM
I sent my final follow up at 4:20PM on Aug 11- The Feast of St. Clare of Assisi (name=clarity/brightness). After a cycle of hush-hush praise and public quite, my "one more time" lands on a day literally themed around clarity. Meme timing meets liturgical irony.
Why it lands: It reads like the arc closing: after deflection and "retreat," the correspondence resurfaces on a feast about seeing clearly. I didn't plan it; but it still plays.
Bonus Points: In the bible Mathew 4:20, this is the verse in the Gospel of Matthew where it depicts the moment when Jesus calls Simon Peter and Andrew to follow him, and they immediately respond by leaving their fishing nets and becoming his disciples.
Family & Apostles- July 25-26
July 25: You mark the break with your parents (Feast of St. James the Apostle), a day tied to costly discipleship.
July 26: Cardinal McElroy replies on the Memorial of Saints Joachim & Anne (Mary's parents)- a feast centered on parents/family. The sequence is brutal poetry: Family rupture - "church-parent" response.
Why it lands: The calendar theming (parents/heritage) mirrors the content (my family, the church as family.) Even as coincidence, it's narratively airtight.
Discernment- Transfiguration- Clarity - July 31, Aug 6, Aug 11
- July 31: My follow-up routes through New Ways around St. Ignatius of Loyola (discernment/retreat/spiritual exercises).
- Aug 6: Sister Jeanine replies on the Feast of Transfiguration- a literal feast of radiant change on a mountain.
- Aug 11: My 4:20 note on St. Clare- again, clarity/light.
Why it lands: The arc names itself: discernment- transformation- clarity. You couldn't script a tighter theological storyboard.
"Daring God"- Why They Can't Dismiss It
I wrote that I "dared God' and a reply landed "in that very moment. "Even if a skeptic calls it coincidence, two facts hold:
1. The record is fixed. The timing of replies and the "retreat" dodge are in their own emails- not my interpretation. The pattern (private praise, public quiet, stall) is objective.
2. The dare is rhetorical judo. It forces a lose/lose for the institution: either acknowledge the timing (granting gravity) or wave it off (and look like they're ducking their own pastoral language about discernment and signs). In a church that urges believers to notice providential timing, dismissing your timing outright undercuts their message.
Bottom Line: Whether you call it providence, pattern, or parody, the receipts stand. The "dare" isn't about proving miracles; it's about proving mechanics- the compassion-deflection cycle I documented.
The Morningstar Paradox
Morningstar, Lilith, and Jesus- why they can't escape it.
"Morningstar" isn't just a name. It's Lucifer, the rebel star- the one who refused submission. But in Revelation, it's also Jesus calling himself the "bright morning star." The church has always worked overtime to split those meanings, but the timing of my letters forced them to overlap. My exchange fell across the Feast of St. Anne and the cycle of Transfiguration- family, light, rebellion. Their own calendar staged paradox: Lucifer and Christ, fall and glory, collapse into one word.
And then there's Lilith - the archetype of the first wife, the shadow they wrote out of their canon because she wouldn't bow. That's the other name I carry. To them, it's blasphemy stacked on blasphemy: Morningstar, Lilith, and Jesus stitched into one thread. But here's the trap- they can't dismiss it without admitting their own scriptures and feast days wrote a script before I ever touched it. That's why they called it "beautiful" That's why they're stuck.
"I haven't even read the Bible- and still cornered them with their own calendar"
Uncover The Full Story
View all-
Cave Springs and the Manufactured Outrage Mach...
Cave Springs, Arkansas has become a case study in corruption and manufactured outrage. In 2025, Mayor Randall Noblett and the City Council staged a false IRS “tax crisis” to strip...
Cave Springs and the Manufactured Outrage Mach...
Cave Springs, Arkansas has become a case study in corruption and manufactured outrage. In 2025, Mayor Randall Noblett and the City Council staged a false IRS “tax crisis” to strip...
-
The Compassion–Deflection Playbook: How the Chu...
When the Church called my letter ‘beautiful’ in private but turned silent in public, they didn’t just confirm my suspicion—they handed me proof.
The Compassion–Deflection Playbook: How the Chu...
When the Church called my letter ‘beautiful’ in private but turned silent in public, they didn’t just confirm my suspicion—they handed me proof.
-
How the Eden Protection Act Actually Disrupts t...
The Eden Protection Act isn’t about silencing speech—it’s about ending the weaponization of suffering. For too long, political operatives have turned grief into a business model, exploiting children’s stories for...
How the Eden Protection Act Actually Disrupts t...
The Eden Protection Act isn’t about silencing speech—it’s about ending the weaponization of suffering. For too long, political operatives have turned grief into a business model, exploiting children’s stories for...





Catch Up to Christ Not Culture- Unisex Graphic Tee
Share















